Now Reading
National Peanut Butter Cookie Day: Get your fix, Columbus style

National Peanut Butter Cookie Day: Get your fix, Columbus style


People, it’s Friday. You made it. Now, reward yourself with a much-deserved and well-earned peanut butter cookie in celebration of National Peanut Butter Cookie Day! (And for those of you with nut allergies, just go eat any kind of cookie you can!)

Columbus has a lot of options when it comes to local bakeries and their ability to make mouth-melting cookies. Check out the list below of Columbus bakeries so you can celebrate the day properly.

Resch’s Bakery – 4061 E. Livingston Ave.

Six generations of bakers. Over 100 years old. Resch’s Bakery is iconic. I mean, if you can sustain a family-owned business for over a century, you’re doing something right. The bakery moved to its current location on E. Livingston in the 1960s, and that’s where it’s been ever since. Stop in for one of their peanut butter cookies and a dose of Columbus pastry history.

Schneider’s Bakery – 6 S. State St., Westerville

For nearly 70 years, Schneider’s Bakery has been servicing the Westerville community with delicious delicacies. From pies to cakes to muffins, Schneider’s has your sweet tooth covered. Grab a peanut butter cookie for $0.80 or grab a dozen for $9.60.

Rogue Bakery – ONLINE ONLY

The self-proclaimed “artisan” cookie bakery is here for you if you’re not so sure about walking into a bakery just yet. Rogue Bakery only takes orders online and doesn’t operate out of a traditional storefront. That just means they’re putting extra care into your cookies. Check out the list of creative flavors here to see if you can get your peanut butter fix.


Mozart’s Bakery – 4784 N. High St.

After relocating to Columbus from Austria in 1995, the owners Doris and Anand Saha opened Mozart’s Bakery. Wanting to bring over the best of European treats to the United States, Doris has made it her passion to keep the authenticity of European desserts alive and well in Clintonville. A peanut butter cookie at Mozart’s will cost you $2.50. You can also purchase a dozen for $30.

Lion Cub’s Cookies – DELIVERY

Another cookie delivery service? I might not get out of bed today. Want to assure your child’s satisfaction with a monster cookie? Lion Cub’s has your covered. Even with just one year of experience, Lion Cub’s has emerged as a new favorite around town. You can purchase cookies in pairings of six for $20 from the Lion Cub’s Cookies website.

View Comments (810)